Duties of a doctor prevention is better swot analysis. Application part ii the competition and consumer protection commission 4. Medical profession and consumer protection act doctor. However, in some cases the patient died before he reached the hospital. Anyone who wants to know exactly how the legislation affects them should refer to the act itself and in case of doubt should seek legal advice. The 2015 bill acknowledged that the rapid change in consumer markets, introduction of practices such as misleading advertisements, and new modes of transactions online, teleshopping. Table 2 compares the provisions of the 1986 act with the 2018 bill. Recently, the act has been amended by the consumer protection amendment act, 1993, w. Consumers are often given a raw deal by way of substandard products, increased prices by market manipulation, failed warranties, poor after sales services, etc.
Standard books on medical jurisprudence contain excellent chapters on the law in relation to doctors. If you are a business owner, make sure you know about and follow the state consumer protection laws that apply to your business. The law is not enforced to penalize all health care professionals that cause injury to the patients. Medical negligence liability under the consumer protection. Often the deficiency in service or defect in goods is the outcome of negligence of the service.
Consumer protection act and medical profession collusion, says the much venerated oxford english dictionary, is a fraudulent secret understanding, especially between ostensible opponents. The doctor is expected to provide the treatment agreed to, tacitly or expressly, according. Under the law of torts a wrong that is independent of contract civil liability is applicable to doctors of all categories, that is whether they provide their service for a fee or as. As the medical profession has been brought under the provisions of the consumer protection act, 1986, the patients have an easy method of litigation. After the consumer protection act, 1986, has come into force some patients have filed legal cases against doctors, have established that the doctors were negligent in their medical service, and have claimed and received compensation. The law of contract, the consumer protection act and. Negligence is an offense under tort, ipc, indian contracts act, consumer protection act and many more.
The bill replaces the consumer protection act, 1986. Consumer protection act blessing or curse to medical profession. Protection act, professional negligence, complainant, complaint, consumer. Examining the consumer protection bill, 2018 prsindia. Medical profession and consumer protection act selected. Consumer protection act and medical profession list of acts. The industrial revolution and the development in the international trade and commerce has led to the vast expansion of business and trade, as a result of which a variety of consumer goods have appeared in the market to cater to the needs of the consumers and a host of services have been made available to the consumers like insurance. Shantha 1995 6 scc 651 doctors who administer the morphia or pethidine injection are often blamed and cases of medical negligence are filed against them. After including the amendments made vide the consumer. Consumer protection act and medical profession definitions. Now that the dust has settled it is worth examining how the medical community has responded to the very positions it tried to take.
The pharmacy act, 1948 the transplantation of human organs act and rules. After the medical profession was brought under the consumer protection act vide indian medical association vs. Act 68 of 1986 the consumer protection bill, 1986 was passed by both the houses of parliament and it received the assent of the president on 24th december, 1986. We shall deal selectively with provisions of the act which are relevant to the medical profession, as they exist as on today. Consumer protection regime primarily aims to protect against deficiency in services and defect in goods. Role of consumer protection act in medical practise iamj. Thus, it becomes imperative for health professionals today to be aware of such laws. Good business ethics should consider the customer as a stakeholder and give him his due. Be aware of laws against deceptive advertising and pricing and when they apply. Assent 26th may, 2006 commencement 1st july, 2006 1.
Bur it also noted that with the advent of the consumer protection act, in a few cases patients had been able to establish the doctors negligence. Medical negligence basically is the misconduct by a medical practitioner or doctor by not providing enough care resulting in breach of their duties and. It also creates a regulatory body called the central consumer protection authority and permits mediation for settlement of consumer complaints. Comparison of the consumer protection act, 1986 with the consumer protection bill, 2018. It came on the statutes book as the consumer protection act, 1986 68 of 1986. Consumer protection act in medical profession slideshare.
The consumer protection act 1986 was passed by the indian parliament to protect consumer rights and to redress consumer complaints and resolve consumer disputes. A consumer includes any business with a total annual turnover that is less than. Medical negligence and legal remedies with special reference to the consumer protection law. Aims of cpa, 1986 this act aims to provide better protection to the interests of the consumers to make provisions for the establishment of consumer councils and other authorities to provide speedy and cheap remedy to the consumers. The consumer protection bill, 2018 was introduced in lok sabha in january 2018.
Medical profession and consumer protection act issues. The below mentioned article provides highlights on the consumer protection act, 1986. The mdc assists the board in its deliberation of issues important to consumer protection and the veterinary medical profession in california by advising and recommending to the board rules and regulations necessary to ensure proper administration and enforcement of the veterinary medicine practice act. Doctors and the consumer protection act cpa indian. The doctor is expected to provide the treatment agreed to, tacitly or expressly, according to the established medical procedure. This memorandum also provides possible recommendations for the veterinary medical board board to consider submitting to the. The law of contract, the consumer protection act and medical malpractice law by maud letzler maud. The consumer protection act, 1986 which came into force on 15th april,1987 is a welfare legislation mainly titling towards the consumer just as the industrial disputes act is loaded in favour of workers. The recent landmark judgement by the supreme court, stating that medical services to patients, for which fees are charged, come under the purview of consumer protection act 1986, has put a curtain on the long drawnout debate between doctors and consumers on the issue.
The issue will be discussed from a constitutional perspective as. The guide is not a legal document and it does not attempt to cover all the details. Medical negligence and consumer protection law by prashant. The application of the consumer protection act to the medical professionals has only served to bring into focus some of the legal liabilities of the doctors. Vp shantha,5 medical profession has been brought under the section 21 o of consumer protection. Consumer protection act and the medical profession n. Consumer protection actcpa the cpa, 1986 is a benevolent social legislation that lays down the rights of the consumers and also provides means for their promotion and protection. The purpose of this article is to explore if the consumer protection act 68 of 2008 cpa will influence how the courts will look at exclusionary clauses in all contracts, and in respect of hospitals and doctors in particular. Scope of consumer protection act in medical profession in india. Thus, from an early stage the would be doctors are made conversant with the legal issues inherent in medical practice. Pdf scope of consumer protection act in medical profession in india. Consumer protection act cpa aims to protect the interests of the patients in case of any unethical treatment rendered by a medical or a dental health professional.
Rights of a consumer the consumers international ci, former international organisation of. Consumer protection act and the medical profession introduction charakss oath b. This paper will examine the question of whether patients, who receive free medical care, whether from private charitable or governmental hospitals, can claim rights as consumers under the consumer protection act, 1986. Selected provisions of the consumer protection act 1986 explained as relevant to the medical profession the consumer protection act, 1986 which came into force on 15th april,1987 is a welfare. The amending law had a seminal bearing on the medical profession and health care system as apparent from the express verbis exclusion of. Important supreme court decisions on medical negligence. Consumer protection act and medical profession find a. The judgment in this case defined medical care as a service that was covered under the act, and also clarified that a person seeking medical. This has decreased the unnecessary harassment of doctors. The medical profession has been very vocal in its criticism of the newly enacted consumer. Free medical care and consumer protection indian journal. Rights of a consumer where can a consumer complain definitions laws in medical profession consumer protection act 1986 cpa who is liable and who is not.
Previously in 2015, a bill had been introduced to replace the 1986 act. Consumer protection act cpa copra related to medical. The state medical council has the power to warn, refuse to. With the inclusion of health care services under consumer protection act, a spurt in litigations arising out of breach in medicaldental profession is seen.
For a detailed analysis and comprehensive study of various cases, issues and arguments advanced for and against the inclusion of medical profession within the jurisdiction of the consumer protection act 1986, see, gurjeet singh, the consumer protection act. These laws protect consumers from unfair or deceptive practices. The supreme court has laid down guidelines for the criminal prosecution of a doctor. Rights of a consumer the consumers international ci, former international organisation of consumer. December, 1986 an act to provide for better protection of the interests of consumers and for that purpose to make provision for the establishment of consumer councils and other authorities for the settlement of consumers disputes and for matters connected therewith. Pdf consumer protection act, 2019 and its implications. The meaning of legal terms are being restricted to such terms only as concern the medical profession. This act may be cited as the consumer protection act. The consumer protection act would ultimately be against the interests of patients because there would be defensive medicine.
Why ball uses this word to describe the holding of a medical conference by a medical association is beyond comprehension. Since the passing of the consumer protection act in 1986, c lways been a. Consumer protection an act to make provision for the greater protection of consumers, to establish a consumer protection commission and for the functions and powers of that commission and related matters. But criminal law was pressed into service only in cases of death. The realm of medical malpractice was brought under the consumer protection act, 1986, due to the landmark case of the indian medical association vs. Pdf consumer protection act, 2019 and its implications for the. The consumer protection amendment act, 1991 34 of 1991.
3 73 752 1558 1516 1392 686 1421 1344 852 1397 789 873 756 34 434 280 1141 960 931 426 752 1509 1180 1510 1274 1085 477 135 483 972 1235 260 1440 157 1093 177 1480